Afraid To Meet With a Financial Advisor? Here’s How the First Meeting Goes – 2GYM 057

December 4, 2013 by Average Joe 1 Comment

Never met with a financial advisor and worried about what will happen? OG & Joe pull back the curtain this week and show you how the meeting SHOULD go while cautioning you against how it MIGHT go.

Subscribe to the podcast through iTunes and new episodes will show up every week!

Never subscribed to a podcast before? Here’s Apple’s fantastic tutorial.

Would you rather listen on your smartphone? Try Stitcher or the iPhone podcast app. We’re available on both platforms, as well as Windows Phone, Blackberry Podcast App, Podcatcher, TuneIn, and more!

Show Notes

<> Open

<> Amazon.com – Hunting for gifts this holiday season? If you’re shopping on Amazon.com, how about using the 2 Guys & Your Money Amazon link? You’ll still get the same great Amazon deals while also helping the show. Thanks! Here’s the link.

<> Meeting With a Financial Advisor For The First Time

What questions should you ask? What should you expect? What SHOULDN’T you expect? Joe & OG have a discussion (and a few disagreements) about that first meeting and how to choose an advisor.

3 Easy Steps to Increasing Investment Returns

April 23, 2013 by Average Joe 39 Comments

Hello Free Financial Advisor readers! I’m Marvin from Brick By Brick Investing, a blog that focuses on teaching the average joe how to invest in the stock market and grow their wealth in order to achieve financial independence. It’s my pleasure to have you as my audience today. If I could explain one thing to investors it would be this…

Investment returns are not the number one factor in regards to building wealth through the stock market. Now before you strike me down and start to curse my name hear me out. I pride myself in being completely honest with you and if our roles were reversed I would want you to do the same. Here are the three things that you have complete control over that matter most.

Earn More Money

While some make the noble attempt to educate themselves financially it has been my experience that they prematurely start investing and in return lose a substantial amount of money. I would advise instead of focusing all that energy chasing hot stock tips, attempt to be the best in your field. Strive hard for that promotion at work or for that bonus and when you achieve success allocate your increase in income to your overall portfolio. I would much rather see a safe low risk return of 6-8% on a portfolio of $100k+ than a high risk return of 15-20% on a portfolio of $10k.

Throughout college I worked hard and was able to levy that hard work into a favorable job market where I obtained a very coveted job skill. In return I was able to start making a large sum of money compared to my peers that I graduated with the year before. It wasn’t easy, there was a lot of sacrifice not only from myself but from my family as well. I basically sacrificed three years of my young adult life in order to acquire a nice salary. Now I am able to make low risk trades and investments and compound my wealth.

Increase Your Savings Rate

Stop trying to keep up with Joneses and stop living above your means. Eliminate your debt and spend less than you earn while investing the rest. I believe a good bit of us have been deployed and lived under basic conditions. Therefore I believe it is safe to say you can do without some of the luxuries that deplete cash from your wallet. I personally recommend that individuals should strive to save 50% of their income AFTER tax.

Time and time again I hear that this cannot be done but I did it for two years of my life. In fact I use to save 80% of my after tax income before I got married. I will never forget the day my wife discovered that I used shirts on hangers as curtains for my room, her facial expression was priceless. For six months I had nothing more than a mattress, laptop, and gorilla case in my room. These are the things that allowed me to save so much money at a young age. Since then my wife and I have come to happy medium and we save 50% of our after tax income and indulge in some luxuries but if it were up to me we could save a lot more.

Choose A Great Financial Advisor

While no fault of their own a lot of individuals believe all financial advisors are created equal, but the harsh reality is they are not. It is imperative that you verify potential advisors credentials, fee structure, and capabilities. Some advisors may try to use a broad stroke with all their clients and you need to verify that your potential advisor has a plan for your specific situation. Do not feel that you cannot ask questions. In fact you are interviewing them for a job to manage your investments. Ensure that you leave no questions unasked and make sure you understand the answers that are given to you. Albert Einstein said, “If you can’t explain it simply, then you don’t know it well enough.”

Increasing Investment Returns Can Be Simple

If you do these three things I guarantee you will outperform 90% of your peers in terms of investing and ensure a successful retirement. These are the things I live, preach, and teach.

Photo: Tony Crider

Jemstep Portfolio Manager Review: Finding the Asset Allocation Middle Ground

April 2, 2013 by Average Joe 15 Comments

How do you review your investments? We give Jemstep a test-drive to see if it’s worth your time and money.

As OG bemoaned last week when writing about his broken garage door, at some point, calling a professional is the right move. In the comments, there were some wonderful discussions about finding “experts” without consulting with a person locally by using YouTube videos, better online tools and calling trusted friends.

The Middle Ground in Asset Allocation

There’s plenty of middle ground between wingin’ it and hiring a financial advisor when picking the right basket of investments. One tool I’ve had the opportunity to test drive is Jemstep. After meeting a Jemstep rep at FINCON last year, I was impressed enough with the product to have Simon Roy, the firm’s president, on our 2 Guys & Your Money podcast. He informed me that they were upgrading the product, and now it’s available.

The “New” Jemstep Portfolio Manager

Jemstep is a program that helps you diversify your investments. You know that dartboard you’ve been throwing at? No longer. Jemstep takes the guesswork out of discovering which investments you should be using and pinpoints suitable replacements for duds (or, surprisingly, good investments in asset classes that really don’t meet your investment needs). During my trial run, JemStep told me some things I’d (shamefully) already knew: I’d let my winners run a little too long, and Jemstep recommended cutting back in those “overgrown” areas where the risks now exceeded the chance for rewards.

How Jemstep Portfolio Manager Works

The Jemstep approach is consistent with that of an advisor. First, JemStep asks you questions about your goals. What do you need your portfolio to do? It asks questions about how far away the goal is, how much you may need to access at a time, and other relevant questions. I found this process fun. The interface is intuitive and the style of the website draws you in.

Jemstep asks you for information about your retirement goal, among others. The interface is easy to use, and the blue lines below tell you just how far you still have to go: I have to still fill in information on my finances and investment preferences.

Once you’ve answered goal-related questions, you can upload your portfolio directly from your broker or add in funds manually. Finally, JemStep does it’s work and voila….gives you the correct asset allocation for your goal.

Jemstep Portfolio Manager basic recommendations

Here is the basic recommended portfolio. With these changes, I stand to gain over $9,000 per year in retirement. Yee-haw!

The premium version of Jemstep includes lists of what investments you should sell (in many cases only trim back), which investments you should accumulate, and new suggestions for your portfolio (often in asset classes that don’t exist in your portfolio). Here’s what that looks like:

Jemstep not only tells me which investments to sell, but alerts me to potential capital gains taxes. Every sell recommendation is accompanied by a detailed reason why this investment is on the chopping block. In this case: Apple is one of my worst performers and I have too much individual stock for a portfolio of this size.

The Cost

The Jemstep pricing model isn’t surprising. You can access basic advice for free (this includes the asset allocation you should be using, plus the differences between your portfolio and the suggested one). The premium model, which includes continuous tracking, rebalancing advice, a detailed breakdown of recommended sale quantities and investments, is also free for people just starting out. Pricing begins at $17.99 per month for portfolios over $25,000, and increases based on the amount of money Jemstep is helping you manage. While some who are looking for a freebie might be turned off by the price, this is less than the 1% fee often charged by a financial pro. Want professional advice in your corner without having to sit in an office with some team of people? Great. Jemstep won’t call you with hot stock tips and is there when you need it. In exchange, you’ll pay a model comparable to those used by seasoned investors for less than half the cost.

What I Like, What I Don’t

Here’s what I love: this asset allocation is a proven winner that points you toward the low cost, high return investments in a balanced portfolio. If you’ve ever wanted to have a well-managed portfolio but didn’t know where to start, Jemstep is a great place to begin. Different than some generic asset allocation models that I’ve used, JemStep points you toward specific investment options. For the person who wants to make sure they have low cost investments with a proven track record, Jemstep is for you.

Jemstep partnered with Windham Capital Management to create their recommendations. When back-tested against the S&P 500, Jemstep’s recommended portfolio was impressive: all five of their model portfolios outperformed the S&P 500 over the last 14 years with significantly less risk.

Here’s what I don’t like: results. Yes, JemStep provides impressive results, but will you use them? As I’ve stated before, financial advisors exist for one reason: to make sure that the job is finished. When people left my office, the portfolio moves were complete and people could go about their lives, knowing that the important decisions had been made. A JemStep rep was excited to tell me that 12% of JemStep users actually made changes to their portfolio “because it’s so hard to get people to take action.”

She’s right on.

While 12% usage is a great number for an often-free tool used by people on the internet, you should examine yourself. Are you going to follow through and actually take the advice on JemStep? If you don’t trust yourself to do the job, pay more and hire a human being who’ll give you a shove.

Overall Impression

If you’re managing your own money and aren’t sure how to do it well, give Jemstep a shot and follow the recommendations. If you don’t like your advisor or wonder if the recommendations you’re receiving are any good, take the time to use JemStep to give yourself a “second opinion.” The tool is robust enough that you’ll know immediately if your advisor isn’t diversifying your portfolio in a way that makes sense for your goals.

Jemstep can be found at Jemstep.com. I am not an affiliate of Jemstep and was not compensated for this review.

Meeting an Advisor? Understand Fees by Bringing This Checklist

May 23, 2012 by Average Joe 9 Comments

Yesterday I posted a riveting story about advisor fees.

How do you know all the fees an advisor may charge?

The good news: this isn’t my first fee-rodeo, so I’ve meticulously prepared and will present to you, hot out of the oven, a fee checklist. Now when you meet an advisor you can ask intelligent questions about what fees you may pay.

Isn’t this exciting? Of course it is. Let’s begin:

___ Advisory fee. This fee is an umbrella fee for services rendered.

What services are included?

Financial plan? Yes / No (how often is the plan updated?)
Budget review? Yes / No (will you advise on line items?)
Net worth review? Yes / No (do you make suggestions on assets for the fee?)

Often advisors say they will recommend new homes for assets, however, those new places are through them, garnering the advisor another fee. Will they make recommendations of funds/ETFs/other investments outside of their control?

Insurance review? Yes / No (In many states advisors can’t review insurances for a fee. However, they can make recommendations on appropriate amounts of insurance.)
1040 review? Yes / No (Again, advisors have to be careful here. Some aren’t allowed to give specific tax advice.)
Tax strategy? Yes / No (Will you recommend comprehensive tax plan?)
Asset allocation? Yes / No (Many advisors will calculate where your assets lie on an Ibbotson efficient frontier and recommend asset changes based on your goals.)
Estate review? Yes / No

___ Wrap fees on personally managed funds. Sometimes an advisor will charge fees based on the percentage of assets inside of an account. Often, these fees range from 0.5% to 2.0% Remember that funds inside these plans have fees also, so ask what the average fee is for funds inside the account and add it to the fee.

___ Wrap fees on outside managed funds. Often advisors will recommend outside advisors to manage all or a portion of your assets. Fees generally range from 0.5% to 3.0% of assets managed, per year.

Wrap accounts are easy to remember if you think of plastic wrap around your assets managed in the account. Instead of trading and holding fees, you’ll pay the “wrap” fee on the entire amount inside of the wrapper.

__ Trading costs. Are there commissions for trades? What would those be?

__ Commissions to buy funds. Does the advisor use mutual funds? Are there fees to buy, sell or hold the fund? What are those fees?

__ Insurance commissions. If the advisor completes an insurance analysis, are you expected to buy insurance through them or do you go outside? What types of insurance does the advisor make recommendations on?

When I was an advisor, I’d recommend an insurance amount needed. Then I’d prepare quotes through companies I represented and recommended my clients shop other firms, such as Zander insurance (Dave Ramsey’s company).

__ Annuities, Private REITs and Limited Partnerships. Does the advisor recommend these product types? Do they receive commissions when they recommend these products? Annuities may pay up to a 9 percent commission. Often REITs (real estate investment trusts) will pay nearly the same amount to the advisor.

__ Cash products. Do you recommend savings accounts, CDs and other similar cash accounts? Are these through you, banks or credit unions? How do they work?

__ Mortgages, auto loans and revolving credit. Do you recommend these products for a commission?

__ Other outside experts. Should I expect to pay other experts, such as attorneys (estate plan) or CPAs (tax review)? If so, it’s important to know that there may be even more fees after you write your first check.

In Defense of Financial Advisor Fees

May 22, 2012 by Average Joe 20 Comments

I was a fee hater.

Like a younger, more handsome John Bogle, I would rail on fees. I’d stand on every rooftop screaming about avoiding fees at all cost.

For this reason, when I was a financial advisor, I provided what I thought was top-notch service and undercharged for it every day.

How much did I charge? My minimum fee was $500 per year.

Undercharged? There is no such thing, Joe! Less fees = better. Duh! You should have charged $300!

Think so, do you? Sit close, young padewan, while Uncle Joe tells you a story:

My Experience With Fees

Early in my career I lucked into the opportunity to give speeches on behalf of one of the top advisors in the country. I’d fly wherever he wished and spoke to rooms full of people about good planning. In exchange, he allowed me to move my offices into his suite.

Awesome! What a break for a new advisor; I’d get to see the inner workings of a well-honed operation and maybe glean some tips.

At first I was disappointed. All I saw was what looked like a cookie-cutter assembly line of advice and deliverables. Many clients received offshoots of similar advice. The firm never stuck their neck out. They avoided complex situations at all cost.

That lead me to believe that he was among the best in the country only because he could “sell” people on ways he’d jack up their fees.

…and jack he did. I rarely saw him charge less than $2,500 for planning, then garner asset management fees on top of that. He was a fee-based selling machine.

One day the operations manager and I were talking. I asked a polite question about how redundant their process management workflow seemed. To give you an idea of what I thought about this guy: I’m sure the term “cocky smartass” wouldn’t be far off the mark.

He said, “Have you noticed that we charge five times what you charge?”

I smiled. “Yes.” What a loser. I could never charge what they did! They were just leeches, skimming off of their client’s blood.

He said, “We charge five times more because we’re five times better than you.”

I took it personally.

I shouldn’t have.

Three months later, we were in agreement:

he was five times better than me.

Why He Was Better

This planner was so good, I’d worked right under his nose and hadn’t noticed his skill. The systems were sublime. Where I’d seen cookie-cutter assembly lines before, now I saw a brilliant asset allocation arrangement. Where I’d believed he was charging excess dollars to put boring plans in place, he was dotting every “I” and crossing every “T” for clients…mostly doing the boring stuff that usually was swept under the rug.

In short, he had a proven system of asset management and plan building. If you wanted that service, he covered his costs with his fees. If you didn’t want it, you should probably look elsewhere.

He didn’t try to be everything to everyone.

What You Can Learn

You don’t have to pay $2,500 or more to some advisor if you’re willing to perform the critical tasks that this advisor captained for his clients:

1) Design a plan that covers the six areas of financial planning and rigorously maintain the plan according to a set schedule. Make sure everyone involved is up-to-speed with the details.

2) Build a system to check and maintain your assets against your plan. He had systems in place to notify him when assets deviated too much from the plan. Build your own set of alarms.

3) Carefully guard against taxes and excess fees. This seems like an oxymoron, because this advisor charged a ton of money, but his fees were largely performance based. To increase his fees (and his client’s net worth) he had to ensure the plan was a lean-mean-return-gathering-machine. The only way to do that was to develop a comprehensive tax strategy (example: tax efficient investments outside of IRAs while tax-eaters inside shelters) and low-cost investments.

4) Scour insurances for opportunities. This advisor would review all of his client’s insurances regularly (every two years) to find wasted money. He’d also use insurances wisely to plug holes. One place he nearly always recommended: disability coverage.

5) Build legacies. He was the adamant that everyone either had a family or charitable organization they’d want to have flourish if they couldn’t use their own money. He’d make sure that the estate plan was air-tight and (as with insurance) review these plans every two years.

6) Set communication systems. Clients received a newsletter every six weeks. There was a conference call scheduled for two quarters of the year, along with two face to face meetings. Generally, the face to face meetings were comprehensive and the phone calls were “just checking up.” While he “allowed” only one member of a marriage to take part in phone calls, he was adamant that both spouses attend meetings. He’d become especially irate if one didn’t understand finances and didn’t want to participate. His thinking: if the knowledgeable spouse passed away, the other was screwed.

He also wasn’t afraid to call every client when markets imploded. During the 2002 and 2008 crisis, his whole team was on the phone non-stop, sharing information and passing along strategies. Usually, he wasn’t changing course, because his asset allocation model was already designed to weather downturns. However, clients loved hearing from him.

Was some of this overkill? Maybe. Often insurance and estate planning needs didn’t change. However, when something did, the advisor was on top of it fairly quickly.

It’s a Choice

During my 16 years as an advisor, there were many clients who refused to pay fees even though they would have been far better off had they paid this advisor. It’s fine to accomplish your financial goals without an advisor (in fact, if you’re willing to complete the six steps above, I’d recommend it). But if you decide not to, make sure you’ve designed systems for success and aren’t just being cheap.

Financial planning is just one example. Are there areas of your life where you’d be better off paying a fee and you just can’t do it? Are you cheap?

(Photo credit: Hands Clenching Dollars, Muffett, Flickr; Couple and Advisor, Jerry Bunkers, Flickr)

5 Good Reasons to Hire a Financial Advisor and 2 Bad Ones

March 7, 2012 by Average Joe 15 Comments

The decision to hire an advisor to help with your financial planning isn’t a step I recommend lightly. I’ve been lucky: over 16 years of practice I was hired mostly for good reasons, although some others were….not so much.

Most people don’t need a financial advisor.

I’d tell individuals before they hired me that 90 percent of what I did, they could do themselves. My job was to guide them through sometimes stormy financial waters. As a bonus, I’d save them time and money by already knowing tricks they could probably find online. My staff would fill out annoying paperwork, and we had access to the best professionals in related fields. If you needed good advice, I either could provide it or knew how to find it fast.

In fact, at some points I was more of a concierge than a financial advisor….while most of my contacts were finance-related, I knew good babysitters and how to get a table at the top restaurants in town!

Here are five good reasons to hire a financial advisor:

1) You don’t have time.

I worked with many successful people who could have easily completed their plans alone. Most of my clients were engineers or executives working for Microsoft and Chrysler. These were intelligent people (often financially savvy, too).

They recognized that they needed a good plan drafted that they could examine and sign off on. They also needed someone to facilitate the legwork. It had to be someone knowledgeable who had their back. They needed to be able to review everything on a plane or between meetings.

2) You aren’t going to look at the stuff yourself.

Some of my clients were smart people, but in completely different areas. I had a client who was a very well-known artist. He needed to be forced to have consistent meetings about his meetings. Without me, he wouldn’t ever review how he was doing.

3) You don’t want a full financial education.

This type of client would sometimes frustrate me, but I had a large number of them as clients. Different from my artist and executive clients who were generally well educated, financially savvy people, these clients would just rather pay me to do it.

These clients were very happy to meet with me and talk financial planning. They’d listen and nod. I was pretty sure that they were getting the basics about what we were talking about. I tried to keep it entertaining, because I knew they hated being in my office.

Some were looking for the concierge treatment. For those people, we had client dinners, good coffee in the lobby and occasionally went to sporting events or concerts. They didn’t care about how the money was managed, as long as it was done with as little input on their end as possible.

These clients sometimes scared me, because if things went wrong, they had no idea why and didn’t want to learn from anyone but me. If this sounds like you, it’s better to hire a good advisor than wreck your financial ship because nobody’s at the helm.

4) You want a smart coach in your corner…

…to steer your plan in the right direction.

Some of my clients I knew were only going to be with me for a short time. My job was to educate them how to do it themselves. Some advisors won’t do this. I was happy to help. I liked talking strategy anyway, so if I had a willing client who was coachable, I’d take them through the process. As a bonus, I handled most of the annoying parts (like filling out Roth IRA forms) because they were paying me a fee. It wasn’t why they wanted me as an advisor, but it was definitely icing on the cake.

5) You want an ally to point out flaws in your strategy.

This was probably my least profitable type of relationship, but the one I appreciated the most. I had a few Do It Yourself investors who already had a complete strategy and just wanted to hire me for a couple of hours a year so they could tell me their strategy. I always had questions, then feedback, and nearly always, adjustments I’d recommend.

One client, Paul, said he specifically hired me because our philosophies clashed and he wanted to make sure his strategy looked good from the other point of view. He thought about his plan so often that he usually had a winning approach, even though I definitely would have rarely completed the plan the way he did.

There are a couple of important reasons NOT to hire an advisor:

1) You want someone to do it for you.

There’s a subtle difference between this person and the one in #3 above. The person in #3 was happy to meet with me every few months and talk about money. They wanted some small amount of “here’s why we’re doing this.”

Then there’s the person who just wanted “take this cash and make it work.”

I care about my former clients. I never can care about your money more than you do. I’m the money babysitter, you’re the parent. Act the part.

2) You want to day trade with a partner.

I had two clients who could never get through their skull that I was very happy that they day traded…but leave me out of it.

Initially we’d separate the portfolio into two sections: the “long term investment” portion, that I’d help steer, and then the “play money” portion that they’d day trade. I’d make clear that they were on their own with the play money account.

Invariably, these two clients would call in a panic and tell me that Jim Cramer had just said something on television and they needed to sell…but what did I think first? Should they sell? Should the go contrarian and buy more? Could I look up some charts for them? Maybe call a couple fund managers and ask their opinion off the record?

No thank you.

The math on my practice worked this way: 150 families, all of whom paid for and should demand my attention.

If I met with each client on average 3 times per year for an hour and a half, that meant 675 hours of meetings. Additionally, I’d call each client twice a year minimum and talk for 20 minutes (assuming there weren’t urgent financial events afoot or you hadn’t called me first). That was another 50 hours.

We won’t even approach all of the emails I sent or returned daily. Remember that I mentioned Microsoft employees? Those people love email.

After 10 hours of preparation time a week and 10 hours of strategy/internal and analysis time (not to mention any marketing we were doing), that left 30 hours for client meetings. After holidays, I worked about 48 weeks a year.

Where was I going to find time to day trade your account?

That’s my story. Now it’s your turn: have you interviewed advisors? How did the meeting go? What did you like/didn’t like about their approach?

5 Jaw-Dropping Financial Advisor Interview Questions

January 24, 2012 by Average Joe 14 Comments

Some people need professional help–not the type I’ve been told to find–but financial help. I’ve met many of these people firsthand. Over my years working as an advisor, it was difficult watching people walk into my office grossly underprepared for a meeting with an advisor know what to expect. I could tell by the look in their eyes that they hoped I was honest and actually knew what I was doing.

I know the look because it’s the same one on my face when I’m talking to an auto mechanic.

Luckily, you’ve come to the right place. There are five questions that are important to ask a financial advisor.

But is that all I need to ask? Five questions?

Nope. Hopefully these start you on the right track to building a dialogue with the advisor about your personal financial circumstances and dreams.

Whether you’ve found the name of an advisor from a friend (good idea), by their reputation (scary), or even through an internet, mailing or yellow pages search (most frightening), you’ll want to still ask these specific financial advisor interview questions. You have seen in the media that well respected names with degrees, certifications and mountains of clout have ended up as bad people. Although these questions won’t make sure that you won’t get ripped off, they will give you a better idea regarding your advisors methods and whether they’ll fit with your long term and short term plans.

Tell me about your education. Listen to their experiences, any testing they’ve taken and professional credentials, such as a Certified Financial Planner (CFP), Chartered Financial Consultant (ChFC) or one of a host of other designations. For “vanilla” financial planning, the two listed above (CFP and ChFC) are the two broad certificate designations. Others, such as a Chartered Retirement Planning Counselor (CRPC) or Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) either are more narrow designations or focus on one aspect of a financial plan.
How long have you been practicing? Suze Orman recommends hiring an advisor who’s been practicing for at least ten years. Back when I started, I thought that advice was complete baloney. Once I’d been an advisor for ten years, I completely agreed with her. Why? Because there are so many nuances and situations that are new in the wide world of financial planning that for the first ten years you’re often running into brand new situations. Your financial life is important enough that you shouldn’t have your paid professional help “practicing” on you.
How does your financial planning process operate? Here’s the scoop: you can throw investment darts as well as any advisor, so you aren’t hiring him for that purpose. People hire an advisor not for the 80 percent of stuff you can do easily yourself, but for the 20 percent that he can do with far more accuracy and efficiency than you.
- The base of any advisor’s work should be encompassed in a written financial plan that’s backed up by hard data. You’ll use this to mark your progress toward your goals and to hold the advisor accountable to their promises.
- This plan can only be written if you’ve taken home some type of survey about your expenses, income, assets and liabilities.
- Finally, you don’t want an advisor who’s only concerned with your assets (unless that’s all you’re concerned about….but I dare anyone to tell me that your budget, estate plan, insurance needs and tax situation don’t all tie into your asset mix). Your plan should place weight on those areas of your financial house that need work now. If you’re talking budget and he’s talking Roth IRA, you know it isn’t a match.
Who will be working with me? In larger practices, experienced advisors often have less-knowledgeable associates who work with some clients. I don’t want to hire one advisor only to find out later that I’ll end up working with another. Make sure you know how the relationship will work before entering into an agreement. The advisor might also have specialists that help out in areas outside their knowledge base. Ask how referral arrangements work between the advisor and any other professionals they recommend.
How are you compensated? Advisors are paid three different ways:
- Fee only. Some people prefer these advisors because they’re only paid to dispense advice. You decide whether to take it or not and generally implement solutions on your own. Although I understand this thinking in a perfect world, I’ll tell you that the people who hired me did so NOT because they weren’t smart enough to plan on their own. On the contrary, I worked with people who were CEOs and CFOs of corporations, experts in taxation, engineers and entrepreneurs. These people had drive. I learned that they didn’t just hire me for knowledge. They hired me to make sure they took the time to implement the plan.
- Fee based. These advisors charge a fee for planning, but may charge an additional fee for managing assets OR receive commissions for some products. I was this type of planner, charging anywhere from $750 per year to $5,000 per year, then collecting both fees and commissions. Critics say these types of advisors “double dip” on charges, and you can end up paying large sums of money. That’s all correct, if my client wanted it that way. I ALWAYS told my clients how to avoid my fees and commissions, and often helped them set up accounts at other places. Once again, it depended on the client. My job was to identify strengths and weaknesses. If they wanted me to babysit their money or there was a product through me that helped better than those elsewhere….I was paid for that additional support.
- Commission only. These advisors will perform financial planning analysis for free, and are only paid when you implement solutions through them. Critics (like me) believe that these plans have to be slanted toward the methods supported by the advisor’s company, because that’s the only way they’re going to bring home a paycheck. I must say, though, that I knew some commission-only advisors who were top people in their field. They would only support a product they sold in the correct situation, and would actively refer people away from their product if it didn’t fit the need.

As you can see, it’s difficult to find a “perfect” set of financial advisor interview questions for your needs. But by asking these five questions, you’ll gain an understanding of the process the advisor uses, their fee structure and how their practice operates. You’ll also see the advisor’s personal history and gain an understanding of their personal feelings. This is a good start. Once you’ve asked these five questions, move toward your goals and find out how you like the advisor’s answers. It’s like hiring a coach: if you don’t listen to them, it was a big fat waste of money.

Want more questions? Try these resources:

NAPFA.org (National Association of Personal Financial Advisors) How to Find a Financial Advisor

CFP.net (Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards) Questions to Ask When Choosing a Financial Planner (.pdf document)

Photo attribution: Icon Checklist (Wikimedia Commons, Ckepper), Discussion (Wikimedia Commons, HBS1908)

That’s my story, now it’s your turn: have you interviewed an advisor before? Any good questions or stories from that experience that our readers might like?

Find the Right Life Insurance Amount in 10 Minutes

November 23, 2011 by Average Joe 6 Comments

Another note from AverageJoe’s Thanksgiving visit to the in-laws:

Dear blog diary,

I’ve just trounced my mother-in-law at Scrabble again. It was absolute luck that the triple word score was open for my play of “austerity.” Of course, I had to hide a U and Y in my sleeve to place a nine-letter score. Luckily, we’ve both had enough “holiday cheer” that she didn’t notice. I know that to be a good son-in-law I should let her win, but not until I get a chance to play the word “bailout.”

Between all this winning and making Rice Krispies Turkey Pop Treats, I totally can’t be bothered to post anything today. Instead, I’ve opened the basement and let out The Other Guy, so named because he’s still a practicing financial advisor and doesn’t understand that being associated with me would totally be good for business. Whatever.

We’ll have a special piece tomorrow, but will completely understand if you don’t have time to read it. Safe travels, everyone!

Now, on to the Other Guy:

A couple of weeks ago, after being sick for about 10 days, I finally went to the doctor. Apparently, I have ‘walking pneumonia.’ I told the doctor that I don’t do any physical exercise, including walking, so I couldn’t possibly have “walking” anything.

In any event, I didn’t feel well. I began to contemplate my own mortality and then an idea popped in my mind: let’s spend a couple of days talking about life insurance! It’s obviously everyone’s favorite topic…and as a financial advisor who doesn’t like to be sold some insurance, I make the perfect teacher. As AverageJoe did with the “evaluate a mutual fund in 10 minutes” post, I’m going to break it down nice and easy for ya’.

Here goes:

Before anything, let’s not waste time evaluating coverages if we don’t have to. All too often, insurance sales professionals and financial advisors will just make the assumption that you need it and proceed to sell it to you. Here’s an easy way to determine if you need life insurance at all:

Questions to ask:

Does anyone rely on you for financial support, either right this moment or if you got hit by lightning?

If you’re single and/or have no dependents, there’s almost a zero point zero percent chance that you need life insurance. I might be convinced that a small group policy so that someone can bury you is adequate. If you have charitable intentions, there are insurance strategies that work really well….but that’s all. Nothing more.

Don’t let an insurance salesman tell you otherwise.

For those of you who have people relying on you for financial support here’s an easy way to calculate how much you need. Is this the best way? Nope. However, once we walk through these steps you’ll be on your way to making a good insurance decision.

Every life insurance discussion contains assumptions. You’ll need to make some to decide what amount is right for you. At the least, you’ll need to know where assumptions have been made, so you’re able to change directions if you need to.

Here are a few assumptions:

If married, I usually assume with clients that they’ll want the mortgage paid off when they die. Even if both spouses have a full time job and can still afford the house, I’ve seen too many people “go off the deep end” when their spouse dies to determine whether everything will remain stable at work and home. I can understand leaving this out, but at the least I’d evaluate your insurance cost with and without this cost before deciding to drop it.

You may find the additional cost is worth the pain.

If you have children, I assume you’ll want them to go to college, and you’ll want it paid for . Maybe not Harvard or Yale, but you want them to have some level of in-state public university education. Since college costs increase 8-10 percent per year on average, this is one of the most expensive budget items a family can face.

Let’s have the discussion here that we’ll have in client meetings: Maybe you paid for your own college expenses. Evaluate your children and savings and not your personal situation when you went to school. With costs rising quickly, do you want them to have this burden?

Here’s how much life insurance you’ll need…plus or minus the assumptions above plus a few more below.

Add together all of your debts, including your mortgage: $__________________

I’ve done the math on an average in-state tuition in the chart below. Add in these costs: $__________________

Next, we’re going to give your family basic income to live on. Here are where we need to make some large assumptions. Take your annual post tax (take home) income and multiply by 80%. This assumes that your family will live on 80 percent of your current salary if you’ve died. There are better ways to do this. Instead, determine what percent your family would need in the event of your death and use that percentage.

Divide this amount by .05. This means that you’ll need to peel off 5 percent to live on. This single number creates (again) huge assumptions. The biggest? It’s that you’ll continue to live on this income stream even as inflation skyrockets. Once again, we’re trying to get in the ballpark, so if you’re trying to do this the “quick and dirty” way, we’ll be close, but there are better ways.

Place your answer here: $__________________

Add up these 3 lines, that’s how much you need.
$__________________

Now, often, I’ve seen insurance salespeople stop at this point. Not good. Remember, you have some current savings! The goal of insurance in most situations is to replace income that you don’t yet have.

Subtract the amount of money you already have saved from the final number.

$__________________
Buy the difference.

Education Chart

Age	$ needed today	Age	$ needed today
0	$78,855.87	11	$64,200.32
1	$77,395.57	12	$63,011.43
2	$75,962.32	13	$61,844.55
3	$74,555.61	14	$60,699.28
4	$73,174.95	15	$59,575.22
5	$71,819.86	16	$58,471.98
6	$70,489.86	17	$57,389.16
7	$69,184.50	18	$56,326.40
8	$67,903.30	19	$34,071.75
9	$66,645.83	20	$23,139.91
10	$65,411.65	21	$11,792.45

Later, we’ll have a discussion on the various types of insurance you should consider and the #1 question you should ask before you buy anything from any insurance sales person.

As always, this exercise is more about understanding the variables that go into making a good decision as much as it is about the final product. Plug in your own unique situation and evaluate many types of coverage thoroughly before buying life insurance.